Google AI Overviews Criticised for Providing Harmful & Wrong Answers

With the rapid integration of artificial intelligence in everyday technology, it’s easy to forget that not all advancements are foolproof. A striking example is Google’s AI Overviews in search, which has been under fire for delivering misleading, incorrect, and even dangerous responses to user queries. For those who may not know, Google’s AI Overviews is currently an experiment in Search Labs, which allows users to view a summary of the question’s answer and provides access to additional AI features in Search. In this article, we’ll discuss the depths of this issue, examining why it matters to Google’s users and the ramifications.

The AI Overview Fiasco

Google has enjoyed a long-standing reputation as the go-to source for reliable information, but that reputation is taking a hit. The recent rollout of AI Overviews has sparked criticism for generating incorrect or potentially harmful answers. Various examples have surfaced online, drawing significant attention from mainstream media and social platforms.

The AI-generated responses, despite being tagged with a disclaimer stating “Generative AI is experimental,” are often accepted by users as accurate. The public backlash has been swift and severe, highlighting the risks associated with relying on AI for critical information.

Examples of AI Overviews Gone Wrong

Social media users have shared numerous instances of AI Overviews failing spectacularly. For example, one query about medical advice led to a response that was not only inaccurate but potentially life-threatening. Another instance involved historical facts being misrepresented, leading to public misinformation.

Google’s official stance has been dismissive of these incidents, describing them as “extremely rare queries” not representative of the overall performance of AI Overviews. This defence rings hollow, especially when considering that 15% of Google searches are new and unique. Therefore, the excuse of rarity is not a valid excuse, as these “rare” queries represent a significant portion of daily searches.

Why Google Users Care

The importance of accurate search results cannot be overstated, particularly for users who rely on Google as their primary source of information. With the advent of AI Overviews, the stakes are even higher. Misinformation can have dire consequences, from spreading false medical advice to distorting historical facts.

Google’s Response and Accountability

This situation echoes the issues Google faced with featured snippets back in 2017. Featured snippets were meant to provide concise, accurate answers directly on the search results page but often resulted in misinformation. The “One True Answer” problem highlighted the dangers of oversimplified, AI-generated responses. History seems to be repeating itself with AI Overviews as the same fundamental issues resurface.

Instead of Google accepting full responsibility for the issues and promising to make improvements, the company has shifted the blame to the nature of the search queries. This inadequate response, which essentially asks users to deny what they can clearly observe, is further damaging Google’s credibility.

Google search displayed on a laptop.

Final Thoughts

Google’s release of AI Overviews has been fraught with challenges, highlighting the complexities and risks of integrating AI into search functions. The backlash underscores the need for accurate, reliable information and the potential dangers of misinformation. For Google, the path forward involves acknowledging these issues, implementing robust safeguards, and continuously refining its AI systems. We are confident that Google will do so, but it will take a substantial amount of time.

Contact Our Experts for Digital Marketing Strategy

Get in touch with our team of Digital Marketing Strategy specialists who have the knowledge and know-how to fully optimise your social media and website, allowing you to enhance the number of leads and conversions your business gets.

Call our team on 0121 439 5450, alternatively, fill out our contact form.